How to Choose the Right Real Estate Agent When Buying a Home

Are you wondering how to choose the right real estate agent when buying a home? Whether you're a first-time buyer or looking to upgrade, the agent you choose can make or break your experience. A great agent will advocate for you, anticipate your needs, and help you navigate a competitive market with confidence.

In Austin and surrounding areas like Buda, Kyle, and South/Southwest Austin, having a local expert by your side matters. Here's how to choose the right Realtor® for you, and how I, Kaylan Norris, can help guide you every step of the way.

Why Choosing the Right Agent Matters

Buying a home is one of the biggest financial decisions you'll make. A skilled, ethical real estate agent doesn't just unlock doors, they unlock opportunities, negotiate fiercely, and offer clarity through complex paperwork and timelines.

Especially in fast-moving markets like Austin, having someone who knows the local neighborhoods, builder reputations, and offer strategies can save you time, stress, and money.

1. Look for Local Expertise

The best Realtor isn't just knowledgeable about real estate, they're experts in your target market. If you're buying a home in Buda, Texas, you want someone who knows which neighborhoods are growing, where new schools are planned, and what properties actually sell for versus list price.

Ask Questions Like:

• How long have you worked in this area?

• What neighborhoods do you specialize in?

• Can you share recent buyer success stories in my target area?

Austin real estate agent tip: Many agents claim to cover all of Central Texas, but your best bet is someone who works daily in the cities or zip codes you're targeting.

2. Evaluate Communication Style

A good agent listens more than they talk. They explain the process clearly, respond quickly, and check in regularly. Home buying involves many moving parts,you need someone who stays accessible and keeps you in the loop.

Signs of Strong Communication:

• Replies within a few hours (or sooner!)

• Explains contracts and contingencies in plain language

• Proactively sends updates and next steps

Personal Note: One of my clients recently said, "I never had to guess what was happening next. Kaylan kept me three steps ahead the whole time."

3. Check Reviews and Referrals

Don't just take their word for it. Look up Google reviews, Zillow profiles, and testimonials. Ask friends or family who recently bought if they loved their agent. Word of mouth is gold in real estate.

Look for patterns in reviews:

• Were clients satisfied with negotiation skills?

• Did the agent go above and beyond?

• Would they hire the agent again?

4. Understand Their Buyer Strategy

An experienced buyer's agent brings more than MLS access. They help you get prepped, preview properties, and understand how to craft compelling offers. They should have a plan for:

• Educating you on the local market

• Recommending trusted lenders

• Setting up customized home searches

• Advising on pricing, offer strategy, and repairs

• Managing key deadlines during escrow

Let’s Chat! Thinking about buying in Austin, Buda, Kyle, or South Austin? I’m here to help.

Let's Chat

To book a free consultation or shoot me a text with your timeline and goals. Let’s make your move stress-free and strategic.

5. Ask About Their Network

A well-connected agent can save you serious time and hassle. From lenders and inspectors to contractors and title companies, you want someone who can confidently recommend professionals who match your style, budget, and timeline.

Questions to Ask:

• Do you work with any preferred lenders?

• Can you recommend an inspector?

• Do you have go-to vendors for repairs or estimates?

6. Gauge Their Negotiation Skills

The best agent doesn’t just open doors—they open deals. When it comes time to make an offer or ask for concessions, you want someone strategic, assertive, and creative.

Ask how they approach multiple-offer situations. Have they saved buyers money on closing costs? What’s their strategy when inventory is tight?

7. Make Sure They're a Full-Time Agent

Real estate isn’t a side hustle. You deserve someone fully committed to their craft. A full-time agent is more likely to:

• Have current market insight

• Be available for showings and questions

• Handle problems quickly and efficiently

8. Personality Fit Matters

At the end of the day, you want someone who "gets" you. This is a personal journey—and you should feel comfortable asking questions, expressing concerns, and trusting your gut.

Your agent should make you feel heard, respected, and supported.

Bonus Tip: Know What You’re Signing

Make sure you understand the Buyer Representation Agreement. In Texas, this outlines the duties of your agent, your rights as a buyer, and how the agent is compensated. In most cases, the seller covers the commission through the listing agreement.

If anything is unclear, don’t hesitate to ask your agent to explain each section. Transparency is key.

For legal or financial advice, please consult a qualified professional.

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right real estate agent when buying a home doesn’t have to be complicated—but it does require intentionality. Ask questions, trust your instincts, and don’t settle for someone who isn’t invested in your success.

If you're looking for a strategic, supportive, and approachable guide in Austin, Buda, Kyle, or South/Southwest Austin, I'm here to help.

Ready to Get Started?

Contact me today to book a no-pressure consultation. Or, continue exploring my blog for more tips on buying, selling, and making smart real estate moves in Central Texas.

Let's Chat